HOW DARE YOU put this back in the freezer!

But! But! It's actually more work to open the freezer, pull out a drawer, put back the carton, then close the drawer and close the freezer, than it is to simply toss it in the garbage.
Not to mention all the crushed hopes and dreams that can be avoided!

Yeah but my freezer is closer than the garbage.

That's not empty- you can NEVER throw away edible ice cream no matter how little the amount.

Oh, sorry there's one more spoon of ice cream, better save it for someone else!