I wanna see her again this next season. Though if she appears, she'll probably die.

With his finger and his thumb

In the shape of a C on his forehead

Hey now

I don't remember the name but I remember the plot. Dean and Sam go back to their home town for the first time since the fire and meet this witch lady. You should watch it. I think it's either season one or two

The threads up there buddy, although it got down voted for some reason