I always make my character look mildly normal for this reason

Are you kidding? I'll try to make the character as ridiculous as possible because if it.

NIce to see another fan on Jojo around! I'm just trying to imagine what Jotaro would look like in a cowboy hat

Yeah, in Saints Row the Third, my characters honestly looked like government agents of some form. Granted, they were wearing a little purple... gotta rep the Saints yo.