I'd rather have ugly shoes

Even if it's the right fit, the ends are pointed.
If you fit it for your toes, it's going to fall off your foot.

No it’s not.
Your big toe goes at the top in the middle, then the shoe slants sideways as your toes get shorter.

Not everyones toes get shorter sadly. Some are nearly the same, some can even be bigger than the big toe. My second and third are the same as my big toe and only the 4th and 5th are smaller. Its a real inconvenience.

Allow me to demonstrate: https://gyazo.com/ebb3103810ceef294af8835d990ed519

They make insoles for that