When a book doesn't turn out the way you had hoped

One of mine was Conkur's bad Fur Day for the N64. The new one's story was the same so that was good. But the multiplayer was so different and bad when the original was so much fun.

I know the feeling.... That's actually on my list of games where the reboot screwed up something... Not very high on the list, but still on it

Yes, that's the one