I Guess He's Never Really Been a Chick Magnet

That is the proper way to type a title of something. If I were to write a book that the title was 'how to gather read apples' That is not correct. Nor is 'How to gather red apples'.
The correct way is. 'How To Gather Red Apples' it looks neater and it shows it is the title.

That's true. I apologize.