Comments
Follow Comments Sorted by time
guest
· 9 years ago
· FIRST
very long but worth it
34
jmvail
· 9 years ago
OH MY GOD THIS IS SO PERFECT
28
badasslatina
· 9 years ago
I hadn't noticed it, but now that i have, i am very dissappointed on the movies
35
neptunegalaxy
· 9 years ago
I needed to hear this
4
esweeney
· 9 years ago
All the more reason to adapt Harry Potter Game of Thrones style. 7 seasons of Harry Potter!!!
5
alixhill
· 9 years ago
I disagree with the post, lines were interchanged to add humour to an otherwise fairly dark story (e.g Ron's "he's right you know"), plus the films had a much shorter amount of time to portray the characters and their development in each film, meaning key character traits had to be made a lot more prominent.
▼
guest
· 9 years ago
The point wasn't that you shouldn't ever change anything in an adaptation of a book, it was that if you do change something, whether it be to add humor or shorten the story or whatever, it shouldn't be completely against character for them to do it. As an extreme example, if you had a book character that is the physical embodiment of PETA, you wouldn't make them harm an animal for a joke in the movie. By all means add the joke if you think its funny, but have another character do it, one that might actually have done it in the book.
4
guest
· 9 years ago
*bows*thank you in this enlightment
guest
· 9 years ago
GENIUS.
guest
· 9 years ago
TL;DR
▼
thethirdi
· 9 years ago
There were some big words you probably wouldn't have understood so it's best if you didnt read it anyway
4
guest
· 9 years ago
Too long didn't read lololol
▼
thethirdi
· 9 years ago
Im not a huge fan of Harry Potter but while the book readers think this, there are huge differences between those who watch the movies and those who read the books. Not everyone reads the books so if some crazy feminazi saw Hermione with some major flaws I'm sure there would have been an uproar. But reality check. It's never been about following the original series. It's been about the money and to get money you must target the right audience and you all know it.
▼
