Who's your crush?

Friendship?!

We do have a friendship going, at least, but all signs point to her being aromantic as well. Regardless of that, I'm just a high school student. Just because the first girl that I've had a crush on for far too long can't reciprocate doesn't mean the next however-many won't. Besides, I'd probably be a terrible boyfriend.

Well crap, now I'm wondering if I'm friendzoning anyone by being aromantic....

I don't think it counts if you just don't feel that way about anybody, and in fact don't believe 'friendzoning' exists outside of people who use it vindictively. Besides, if they are like me in that they can't get over you despite you not thinking of anyone in that particular way, then that's their problem to deal with, not yours. Just because you like someone doesn't mean they have to like you back, no matter how much you'd be willing to do for them just to have a chance.