She ask for creativity and gave her creativity

Protest the grade.

To have good grades: don't write what you want, write what your teachers want

Realism is an irrelevant standard for fiction, plausibility on the other hand is very important.

Creativity doesnt mean it has to be implausible. A story can be both plausible and creative.

It also isn't very creative; there has been way too much zombie shit for far too long.

This used to happen to me all the time

I reworked a school essay that was supposed to be about why the assinged book was "good" and i wrote about how i thought it was bad. Still got a A. XD