He saw the future

He will always be my favorite Spider-Man

Fuck you, Tobey is da man

Oh yeah looks-way-too-old-to-be-a-high-schooler-and-was-creepy-as-fuck-around-MJ-and-wasn't-witty-at-all-and-made-weird-faces-and-did-that-awful-dancing-Maguire

I wasn't a big fan of his acting (I prefer Tom over him), but I do like how he actually seemed like the nerdy and awkward Peter Parker, which is something that Andrew could not manage.
(Note: I don't dislike Andrew Garfield, I just prefer Tobey for the nerdiness)

pretty much every review I've read says Holland blows Tobey's Spiderman/PP out of the water.

Tobey Magwire made my mom hate Spider-Man. She likely will have to be heavily persuaded just to get Spider-Man Homecoming for us kids.