Compliment and insult

Plus they dont really fit the look or feel of these characters, and as you said they're overused, so people wouldn't really see them as the characters since they're too big name

How about avan jogia and chord overstreet? Not completely unknown but also not that known, and they kind of have the look ( https://www.biography.com/.image/t_share/MTQyMzA3NDYxMDM3MDQxNDk0/avan-jogia-gettyimages-476200174_1600jpg.jpg
https://i.pinimg.com/originals/20/e8/ce/20e8ce74de3cd30ef8664006bfe0e0bc.jpg )

Wow, they definately have the look

I dig it, now they should make the movie