Hi there

Well now you're just horsing around

Nothing wrong with a little horseplay, is there?

Nah I guess you're right. It is fun to foal around sometimes

Glad you agree, and this wasn't just bridle gossip.

Well hay, you seem like a pretty stable person so agreeing is easy with you

You give me too much credit. Dare I say, your compliments are un-colt for.

Nonsense! You are mag-neigh-ficent
In fact, could I ask you equestrian?

Sure. Please pro-steed.

How the heck are you still managing to come up with more puns?! I can't think of aneigh that I haven't already used
It's amhayzing

Well, I minored in filly-ophosy, at the University of Trotterdam. I mane-ly herd these puns there.

Damn... you win mare and square

Very well, I accept. But I mustang you for this thread.

Well ofhourse
It's been an absolute pleasure and it was great punning it out with a stud like you
Guess it's time to rein it in

Yes, to continue would be canter-productive.