Comments
Follow Comments Sorted by time
deleted
· 6 years ago
· FIRST
Yours truly went to the junior Olympics for taekwondo when I was 11, when I truly peaked
8
guest_
· 6 years ago
Wow. That's rather impressive.
2
i_
· 6 years ago
TKD is absolutely not a good martial art for self defense. It should be considering its powerful long kicks but it's been bastardized into this shitty gentle-touch foot-fencing sport.
1
guest_
· 6 years ago
Sport and American TKD yes. As used by more militant and modern styles (like Korean armed forces) the kicks are used to bridge and control distance and hand work is key. But most TKD incorporates kicks meant to dismount horses riders and anticipates "peasant weapons" and other relics. It's also not a simple martial art to be able to use. Many kicks require frequent stretching and practice to be able to perform correctly, you need space (in a largely enclosed modern world), and it takes many years to become an effective fighter for most. The wisdom is never kick someone with a knife, and knives are the most likely weapon you'll encounter in the real world. All in all I'm with you. Lot sense of good reasons to take TKD, and even sport or American give most of the benefits of the more combat oriented styles. It's a fine style but I don't reccomend it as one to rely on in self defense unless your serious about practice and dedicated with a great teacher.
1
i_
· 6 years ago
Or carry a gun.
2
scatmandingo
· 6 years ago
I’ve had my ass kicked before. You get over it. I’d rather that than shoot someone.
1
·
Edited 6 years ago
guest_
· 6 years ago
Guns are... mixed. Closer than 7' of it's not drawn or ready to go you're usually fucked unless you get the drop (but that's not self defense..) which is the next problem. Depending on where you live carrying or using a gun even in defense may end you up in jail. Guns escalate things too. If I'm out to cause trouble the first guy that goes down and HARD is the one with a gun. He's target #1. Close in knife beats gun, and with a gun in play "run" stops being an option for them, it's take you out or get shot. I like to take people to shoot and have them sprint a big lap with a holstered pistol, I tell them when they're done run straight to the line, unholster as fast as possible, and fire 4 shots asap. They're usually shakey and fumbly. Most don't even hit the target and most unload the magazine because they can't count. Shooting at a person close up under stress isn't like plugging a deer or paper. You're likely pumping adrenaline and scared. Bonus points: they are faster and take it.
guest_
· 6 years ago
Run. People have weapons, pals waiting, even if you "win" a real fight you're just as likely to end up hurt and or in jail as the attacker. Running is best. Any fighting style isn't bad to take though, just in case you can't run or for its other benefits. "American" and sport Tae Kwon Do are better than nothin but aren't the best for self defense. Kick boxing is a good all around style but some argue lack key points for "average" fights on untrained opponents, and both can be hard to be effectively proficient enough to use if you aren't dedicated to training. Remember all fighting styles can be useful but each has a purpose and history. Choose one which best suits your body type and the type of fight you may likely encounter if you were forced to use it. Most of all find a good instructor who focuses on real world modern fights. Good instructor>style that's applicable to modern life>style that suits your body type best.
1
·
Edited 6 years ago
i_
· 6 years ago
A good single martial art would be one of the Muay variants. Next would be a ground grappling art, then a standup grappling art.
1
guest_
· 6 years ago
I overall agree. Much like boxing Muay varriants can be complex and skilled arts- or they can be pretty effective and brutal with light training and an ok teacher. They also feed into and off of common sports and exercise hobbies like weights or jogging, cross fit, etc. Elbow and knee strikes are good for tight spaces and protecting your hands and feet of you don't have great form. I hate grappling but most real (unarmed) fights tend to involve it in some way, so I'd say at least spar a grappler from time to time. But for most people grappling arts are also good for defense and knowing how to avoid or escape common grapples. They also don't take a lot of training to use well enough to function, but you can spend a life trying to master them if you want.
·
Edited 6 years ago
regretfulforeigner
· 6 years ago
thai, korean, french