Good guy gym owner

Let's just add the word "factor. Smoking is a negative factor, as is obesity. Both single factors do not decide if a person is generally healthy though. Health is the sum of a lot of decisions people make. Saying "fat people are sick" is just wrong and definitely not helpful.

Fat people are unhealthy. That's a fundamental part of being fat.

Skinny people are unhealthy. That's a fundamental part of being skinny. The general agreement on what is morbidly obese has changed too much over the times to make a statement like that.

That's true too. The trick is being neither to fat nor too skinny. Why is this so hard for you to understand? Are you in denial, perhaps?

How is it me who doesn't understand? I'm not the one with the bold, generalized statements that make no sense when you really look at them.

Being overweight means that your weight is above what is healthy. Being underweight means that your weight is under what is healthy. These aren't bold, generalized statements. These are cold, hard facts about reality, and your claim that they are not merely shows your ignorance to the topic. You are assertimg things that contradict what is known scientific fact with no evidence to support your claims. I am done with you.

"Being overweight means that your weight is above what is healthy. " - Nope. There is no (longer lasting) consensus in medicine what defines normal weight or ideal weight or if this can be defined at all.

Stop lying. https://www.niddk.nih.gov/health-information/weight-management/health-risks-overweight

Start reading what I wrote.