Comments
Follow Comments Sorted by time
spacefactor
· 10 years ago
· FIRST
They put themselves in danger when one of the teachers could take it out in their sleep
21
guest
· 10 years ago
But if they hadn't put themselves in that danger, it might have been too late by the time a teacher found it
3
whocares
· 10 years ago
Exactly. Hermione WAS in the bathroom, after all, and the teachers still thought the troll was in the dungeon and Hermione probably would've been dead by the time they got there if Harry and Ron hadn't come to save her.
5
pancakesandwaffles
· 10 years ago
I feel like of they had just explained EXACTLY what happened minus the real reason Hermione was in the bathroom it would've worked out better.
6
·
Edited 10 years ago
raptorsrule
· 10 years ago
Scumbag McGonagall
2
guest
· 10 years ago
Technically they were in the girls bathroom, not a good look
1
shmurr
· 7 years ago
Well, no matter what happened, they were all breaking the rules, so even though mcgonagall might have admired them, she couldn't show it because other students would think it wasn't fair...
