I can see a less diverse place doing that for the sake of homogeny and not having a kid stand out too much, but in a place like the US, where the spirit of the country is literally "fuck you, I'mma do the thing" it wouldn't go over well. We encourage individuality to the point of crazy, we like it. A better option is easier mechanisms for the kid to change their name later if they hate it.
This is the reason no one in Finland has too weird first names, and weirdo parents who wants to name their child hitler etc. are not allowed. And why there's a little girl in America called Applebutter.
You can very freely choose a name for your kid in Finland. It's not like you have to choose from list of 10 acceptable names. The law just prevents parents from naming their child "hashtag" or "cheese", for example.
Still their child. If I went through hours of labor and squeezing an 8 pound baby out of my girl parts and I want to name it toothpaste, I'll fuckin name them toothpaste.
So y'all heard of the parents that liked the Name "Katelyn" (of however you spell it), but wanted it to be special. So they replaced "ate" with the roman numbers for 8, VIII, and now their daughter is called Kviiilyn. I think it's good to prevent crap like that. Poor child.
In Sweden a family wasnt allowed to name their child "Ikea".. another wasnt allowed "Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmnckssqlbb111163” but they approved "Google"..
"Sorry, that username isn't available. Try Al1234 or Al_6969"
Even though I have to admit that I kind of like the idea of twins named Lemonjello and Orangello