For the most part in our society we use equality interchangeably with equity, and people tend to conflate both to equivalency. No two people are truly equivalent nor are any two crimes. In lay terms- were they equivalent you could replace one with the other and no one would notice. In practice the idea of equality under law is a bit fuzzy in this sense. The idea isn’t a “true” equivalency under law, that’s ridiculous. The idea is that two people; committing the same crime, would receive the same rights, be charged the same, etc. but even in that the sentencing takes in to account the circumstances leading to the crime as well as the circumstances of the crime. A fairly recent example of a bias in law being a young college rapist who was given a light sentence y a judge who said they had too much “potential” in life to “waste” in prison because of being guilty of a crime.
The “equality” in that sentence was not that any person who commits rape would be let off so lightly. It was in that any person deemed to have “high potential value” to society would have been. The same mechanism was at work in post WW2 war crimes trials- with scientists who had valuable knowledge being pardoned death or prison for cooperation while those without such valuable information were hung or imprisoned. It occurs regularly when prosecutions make “deals” for amnesty or immunity protections- people with valuable information that can stop more crime are often given reduced or no criminal sentence for their ill deeds.
So people get stuck in a very narrow view of “equality” when at its core what it means is that two human lives have the same inherent philosophical value. It means that two human beings have the same theoretical potential. Demonstrated potential or immediate practical value are a different metric. Somewhere in the world there is a person who is capable of being the greatest sports star that ever lived but doesn’t play professional sports. But faced with a choice to draft a known all star or an unknown and untested person for the same pay- most any team will take the one that has a known practical value for their purposes.
In essence- the idea of equality doesn’t mean what many make it out to be. It doesn’t mean any human can be replaced by any other, it doesn’t mean any human will get the same results as any other for a given effort or task. It means that regardless of other factors all humans have a basic right to pursue their potential as far as they desire, to live their lives as they choose so long as those choices do not violate laws protecting society and the right of others to do the same.
And I don’t think Sowell is an idiot- but he’s made out to be more than he is. He makes good sound bites and says some things that walk a border between home spun wisdom and self truisms, tending to be tinted with a slight skepticism and said with such authority that they sound good. Ironic considering the man also said (in a negative computation) that Much of the social history of the western world for the last three decades was replacing what worked with what sounded good.
The man is idiotic often and comes from a harsh background- which seems to influence him to a way of thinking that is perhaps justifiable when necessary for survival but doesn’t leave much room for change or progress in a society trying to advance beyond brutality. He can be a real idiot though.
Nope @guest_ @dcottingham said Thomas Sowell is an idiot
Thus he has destroyed, rebuffed, and debunked every idea and word the renowned economist has thought and said
I have now changed the way I think about Thomas Sowell and have lost all respect for him
I only hope to one day be as skilled at debating and changing people's minds as @dcottingham
And Sowell is an idiot.
@dcottingham said Thomas Sowell is an idiot
Thus he has destroyed, rebuffed, and debunked every idea and word the renowned economist has thought and said
I have now changed the way I think about Thomas Sowell and have lost all respect for him
I only hope to one day be as skilled at debating and changing people's minds as @dcottingham