As far as the movie adaptations go, I enjoyed the whole of HP more than I did the whole of TLOTR. The latter, especially The Hobbit part was commercially milked dry, and strayed from the source material a lot.
The Hobbit was worse by far. Watching them after reading the book (and having it read to me as a bedtime story) had me wondering why it was stretched to three movies with at least 4 or so plotlines that absolutely didn't need to be there.
Comments