It's not about the girl or how she looks. It's about the fact they will be her first time. It's been shown many many many many times throughout history and different cultures that there is just something about removing the virginity of a chick that clicks a specific check box in some people.
Idk what I was even expecting when I made my original comment because there really is no explanation beyond the unlimited stupidity of some people. Now the question becomes: how the heck did people that dumb get that much money in the first place I guess
I'm just desperate.