so if someone tries to shoot me or attack me i have to either stand there and take it or try to run away rather than trying to defend myself? If someone is commiting a rape no one is allowed to commit violence to help them? is there not a police force since they cant use violence? how do you try a criminal? they can just walk away and you cant stop them because doing so would be violence.
-
if there are exceptions to this then thats just how basically every country in the world works. If not thats just a society run by criminals who no one can legally stop.
-
that sounds exactly like the rules that schools have here in america. No exceptions super strict no fighting rules in which if you get attacked the only way to not get in trouble in by the school is to let yourself get beaten up risking permanent injury in the process because if you defend yourself, even just enough to try to block attacks or push your way to running away you get the same punishment as your attacker.
No. A person trying to do these things will most likely have had violent tendencies before, so they would be refused to enter the island again.
However, if this happens, when people are intimidating the other person will have an emergency button they'll press and it'll make drones arrive and throw a net at the bad guy.
If that doesn't work or takes too much time, that's the only case where physical violence is allowed.
"A person trying to do these things will most likely have had violent tendencies before"
there is literally no evidence to support that, plus a society set up such a way would actively attract people willing to exploit it.
"If that doesn't work or takes too much time, that's the only case where physical violence is allowed. "
this will have people too scared of being deported from their home to actually be willing to do said violence in your single exception. A drone with nets will be extremely ineffective in that to house a net large enough to affect a human it would have to be huge meaning it would be extremely expensive to run, plus if the person has a gun (which, even if they didnt smuggle it in part by part, wouldnt be hard build there out of stuff bought there and an island with such rules would be ripe for an organized criminal organization to go in and take over like that)
violence from the citizens wouldnt be effective either because they dont have guns.
*troll face*
This time.
Oh yeah that tree is about 40 steps away
-
if there are exceptions to this then thats just how basically every country in the world works. If not thats just a society run by criminals who no one can legally stop.
-
that sounds exactly like the rules that schools have here in america. No exceptions super strict no fighting rules in which if you get attacked the only way to not get in trouble in by the school is to let yourself get beaten up risking permanent injury in the process because if you defend yourself, even just enough to try to block attacks or push your way to running away you get the same punishment as your attacker.
However, if this happens, when people are intimidating the other person will have an emergency button they'll press and it'll make drones arrive and throw a net at the bad guy.
If that doesn't work or takes too much time, that's the only case where physical violence is allowed.
there is literally no evidence to support that, plus a society set up such a way would actively attract people willing to exploit it.
"If that doesn't work or takes too much time, that's the only case where physical violence is allowed. "
this will have people too scared of being deported from their home to actually be willing to do said violence in your single exception. A drone with nets will be extremely ineffective in that to house a net large enough to affect a human it would have to be huge meaning it would be extremely expensive to run, plus if the person has a gun (which, even if they didnt smuggle it in part by part, wouldnt be hard build there out of stuff bought there and an island with such rules would be ripe for an organized criminal organization to go in and take over like that)
violence from the citizens wouldnt be effective either because they dont have guns.
(I'm a generous governor)